Eternally — Judy Blume’s 1975 classic novel about two New Jersey excessive schoolers falling in love and embarking on a sexual relationship — still gets banned to this day. On the time, Blume’s depiction of teenage sexuality was thought of each surprising and groundbreaking, and people of us who learn it rising up are unlikely to neglect it.

Fifty years after its launch, Eternally will get its first-ever TV collection adaptation from Mara Brock Akil, the artistic pressure behind Girlfriends, The Recreation, Being Mary Jane, and extra. In an period of Euphoria and different penis-happy status TV, the brand new Eternally is relatively tame. However Akil’s creation — about two Black teenagers in 2018 Los Angeles — makes its mark in different methods. Whereas it encompasses all of the butterflies and betrayals of old flame, Eternally additionally tells a deeper story in regards to the challenges and heartache of elevating distinctive Black children in our fraught modern period.

Justin Edwards (Michael Cooper Jr.) and Keisha Clark (Greenleaf‘s Lovie Simone) have a meet-cute over fondue at a New 12 months’s Eve occasion thrown by Keisha’s buddy Chloe (Ali Gallow). Justin and Keisha went to grade faculty collectively, and although he doesn’t bear in mind her instantly, he’s immediately smitten. Keisha, now attending a predominantly Black non-public faculty, is working towards a observe scholarship at Howard College. Justin is struggling by means of the tutorial rigors of his principally white non-public faculty, following the trail his mother and father mapped out for him: Northwestern College, his mother’s alma mater, and with luck, a basketball scholarship. As senior 12 months looms for each teenagers, a mutual infatuation begins to blossom.

Akil and her writers take their time letting Keisha and Justin’s story breathe. The primary two episodes comply with the kids by means of the stutter steps of their dance towards couplehood, as miscommunications and misunderstandings maintain their fledgling relationship from getting off the bottom. The pacing can really feel nearly too leisurely in locations, particularly for viewers anticipating swoony-sexy teen-romance motion from the outset. However over time it turns into clear that Akil and her artistic crew — together with Regina King, who directs the primary episode — are telling a narrative not nearly how younger love unfolds, however the way it feels. The digital camera lingers on the little moments: Justin’s face lighting up when he spots Keisha in a crowd as she walks to fulfill him for a date; their fingers tentatively intertwining for the primary time; the agonizing limbo of watching these three pulsating dots whereas ready for a textual content again. Whether or not 50 years in the past or immediately within the period of cell telephones and social media, that nervousness is common: What’s my crush actually pondering?

Finally, Keisha and Justin make their relationship Instagram official. Eternally doesn’t romanticize the kids’ preliminary makes an attempt to consummate their relationship, and as a substitute chooses to depict these early encounters in all their halting and awkward glory. Blume’s frank writing about teen sexuality and need made Eternally a YA classic, however intercourse isn’t the story engine right here. On high of being hormone-addled teenagers blissed out with the magic of old flame, Justin and Keisha are additionally saddled with the daunting expectations of their watchful mother and father, all of whom are decided to assist their kids excel in a world that desires to carry them again. Keisha is so terrified of disappointing her mother, Shelly (The Mindy Undertaking‘s Xosha Roquemore) — who works nights to pay for her non-public faculty — she by no means advised her about an embarrassing occasion involving her ex-boyfriend (Xavier Mills) that also haunts her.

Justin comes from an upper-class household; the Edwards reside in a spacious hilltop home with a pool and spend a month each summer time on Martha’s Winery. Nonetheless, his mother and father — Daybreak (The Morning Present’s Karen Pittman), an government with a self-professed “catastrophic parenting fashion,” and Eric (The Wire’s Wooden Harris), a laid-back restaurant proprietor and chef — know that in contrast to Justin’s white friends, cash doesn’t essentially assure him a simple path to success. “You’re a Black man in America,” Daybreak warns her son. “It is advisable to be plain.”

Although Eternally is Keisha and Justin’s story, Akil and her writers give a substantial about of weight to the mother and father, particularly Eric and Daybreak. It appears ludicrous to write down this in 2025, however the Edwards clan — a well-to-do suburban Black household — are nonetheless very a lot a rarity on TV, and there’s an influence in the best way Akil’s characters don’t simply exist, they thrive. Episode 5, “The Winery,” facilities on Justin and Keisha’s reconciliation after a combat, however the energy of that reunion is rivaled by the joyful scenes of Eric, Daybreak, and their household and mates having fun with a sun-drenched and intoxicating day at their sprawling summer time residence. Even on trip, although, Daybreak can’t cease worrying about what it can take to get Justin into Northwestern. As she laments to her brother Charlie (Rodney Hicks), “It ain’t straightforward getting these children to the dream.”

Like Blume’s novel, Akil’s adaptation units its story of a momentous old flame towards the backdrop of the exhilarating, pivotal, and terrifying interval that’s senior 12 months of highschool. However for Justin and Keisha’s mother and father, securing their kids a spot at school isn’t only a routine cease on the pathway to maturity — it’s an accomplishment born of generational sacrifice. “You’re a first. Get it?” a tearful Eric tells Justin. “Your great-grandfather picked cotton.”

Join Entertainment Weekly‘s free daily newsletter to get breaking TV information, unique first seems, recaps, evaluations, interviews together with your favourite stars, and extra.

Akil understands that younger love isn’t simply an emotional whirlwind for youngsters; it’s a profound expertise for fogeys, too. Wooden and Pittman are phenomenal; actually, it felt like a privilege to observe them embody Eric and Daybreak, characters who’re advanced, humorous, decided, flawed, loving, and totally relatable. (Netflix has categorized Eternally as a drama reasonably than a restricted collection, and I’d be all-in on a season 2 that follows their marriage.)

Simone is magnetic as Keisha, who’s without delay a accountable, pushed younger girl and a giddy, infatuated woman who scribbles Justin’s identify down in her pocket book throughout class. Cooper Jr. provides a star-making efficiency as Justin; the newcomer captures his character’s shy, oddball allure, and he brings an endearing authenticity to Justin’s rising confidence and vulnerability. Regardless of the heady rush of old flame — and the fun of sexual exploration — Justin and Keisha develop a deep, profound friendship, and it’s unattainable to not root for them.

Anybody who’s learn the e book — or, you realize, lived by means of adolescence — won’t be shocked by the trajectory of Justin and Keisha’s story. As Daybreak reminds her son, “Typically love does the onerous factor.” Younger love doesn’t all the time final, however with Eternally, Akil provides us much more candy than bitter. Grade: B+